- What's Trending
- Posts
- All Of Twitter Mocks That Weird “American Boy” Cover
All Of Twitter Mocks That Weird “American Boy” Cover
I feel like I could open up any other magazine to see what straight white people think, but you do you, Esquire.
“I used to threateningly ask people in the service industry if they knew who my father is. That doesn’t even scare them anymore - what happened to my America?”
— Mike Drucker (@MikeDrucker)
2:06 PM • Feb 12, 2019
What does the straight, white male teenage think? It’s a question most of us weren’t asking, because we kind of know. Take one peek at the hundreds of lazy op-eds that talk about how supposedly hard it is to be a man and date in the #MeToo environment (is it harder than either asking for consent or being sexually assaulted? Probably not, but still, a specific audience must be pandered to!). Now Esquire has gone viral for an article for which the word “tone deaf” seemed tailor made, with a cover that no doubt accompanies it in dumb brotherhood: an article titled “The Life of an American Boy at 17”, with the cover boasting that the article will deliver “An American Boy: What It’s Like TO Grow Up White, Middle Class, And Male In The Era Of Social Media, School Shootings, Toxic Masculinity, #MeToo and a Divided Country”, and cover showing well… I guess a white teenager looking sad.
And Twitter had a field day with this. Much was made of the fact that this kid probably has it relatively fine. His troubles included having to check himself, which is something that every other group on the planet has had to do in its entire existence.
finally, the representation we've been waiting for
— Fran Tirado (@fransquishco)
3:53 AM • Feb 12, 2019
Totally baffled by this 7,000+ word Esquire cover story about a run-of-the-mill Republican teen who likes "COOL SNEAKERS" classic.esquire.com/article/2019/3…
— Will Sommer (@willsommer)
7:13 PM • Feb 11, 2019
Because you know what we don’t discuss nearly enough? The white male experience. 🤦🏾♀️
— Jemele Hill (@jemelehill)
12:04 PM • Feb 12, 2019
Imagine this same ‘American Boy’ headline with someone who looked like Trayvon talking about what it’s like to have your mother sit you down to tell you how to stay alive in your own city during Black History Month.
Just imagine.
Shame on you, @esquire.— Zara Rahim (@ZaraRahim)
1:12 PM • Feb 12, 2019
I have to admit it’d be really funny if Esquire gave this kid a cover story every single month just to check in and see how he’s been feeling about stuff
— Chris Scott (@iamchrisscott)
3:31 PM • Feb 12, 2019
Hell, at one point, in the piece, Ryan’s class is asked to give their opinion of gay people, and the point of view we have on that is Ryan’s, rather than, you know, all of the gay people’s opinions on this practice.
Others pointed out that Esquire killed an article outing alleged rapist, director Bryan Singer, in an exposé that was eventually published in the Atlantic. So that Esquire again takes the side against the victims (the article talks about a fight between Ryan and a girl, and ultimately takes Ryan’s side for example) was telling.
I, for one, think it’s very interesting that Esquire is insisting it cares about all teen boys now after trying so recently to kill the Bryan Singer piece
— ✨ Caroline D Framke ✨ (@carolineframke)
3:44 PM • Feb 12, 2019
The real issue is while claiming an extraordinary stance, the article took the side that every article implicitly takes since the beginning of time — that of the straight white man. The thing Ryan is confused about is consequence, and consequence is not new in this day and age, and the situations they consequences are new in is long overdue, and the editor’s defense of the article only hits that point forward. Consequences aren’t new. Blaming others for the actions of white people isn’t new. None of this is new. The only thing that’s new is presenting white people as the victim for simply having to have a conversation about the humanity of other people.
But I don’t know. I’m sure this article has supporters, so I would love to know what you think. Let us know in the comments or on Twitter at @WhatsTrending.
The post All Of Twitter Mocks That Weird “American Boy” Cover appeared first on What's Trending.